Just a hypothetical muscle car value question...

[Jim Ferron]

[ QUOTE ]
Plymouth Superbird makes a 69 Judge look like a Tempest with stripes and decals. 3 foot wing on a street makes this the most recognizable musclecar ever!

[/ QUOTE ]

Sorry, Grandma thinks that wing is a tow bar and how many did they make? 1900? C'mon most of those had dog dishers, like taxi-cabs..boring...

There was an Orange '69 Judge in every showroom.

Unless grandma had a grandson named Cale, she had no clue what that damn Superbird was...

The '69 Judge IS the peoples Muscle Car of all time.

[mockingbird812]

" <font color="orange"> The '69 Judge IS the peoples Muscle Car of all time. </font> "

Gee Jim, I feel like I've been set up. Seems like you already had the answer to your own original question. Here I thought you were looking for opinions. And when did the "Muscle Car of all time" get a coat of Carousel Red paint? Must have missed that in your 1st post. And while you're at it why not make the Chevelle you are comparing it to a gray primer paint for grins and giggles. Next time you ask for an opinion please provide your opinion 1st so we don't provide anything to the contrary. Then "nobody get(s) mad".

[sYc]

[ QUOTE ]
" <font color="orange"> The '69 Judge IS the peoples Muscle Car of all time. </font> "

Gee Jim, I feel like I've been set up. Seems like you already had the answer to your own original question. Here I thought you were looking for opinions. And when did the "Muscle Car of all time" get a coat of Carousel Red paint? Must have missed that in your 1st post. And while you're at it why not make the Chevelle you are comparing it to a gray primer paint for grins and giggles. Next time you ask for an opinion please provide your opinion 1st so we don't provide anything to the contrary. Then "nobody get(s) mad".

[/ QUOTE ]

[rubbinisracing]

[ QUOTE ]
" <font color="orange"> The '69 Judge IS the peoples Muscle Car of all time. </font> "

Gee Jim, I feel like I've been set up. Seems like you already had the answer to your own original question. Here I thought you were looking for opinions. And when did the "Muscle Car of all time" get a coat of Carousel Red paint? Must have missed that in your 1st post. And while you're at it why not make the Chevelle you are comparing it to a gray primer paint for grins and giggles. Next time you ask for an opinion please provide your opinion 1st so we don't provide anything to the contrary. Then "nobody get(s) mad".

[/ QUOTE ]

Exactly! A solicitation for opinions that turns into an opportunity to pontificate.

[Jim Ferron]

Somebodys getting mad? No way, I hope anyway...

Nope, you misunderstood. The question was what car had more value the Judge or the L-78..Not what was the most iconic musclecar of all time. Someone else changed the question, surely I'm allowed my .02 cents worth on the second question. And for the record.

Currently..I don't own a '69 Judge..but I do own a 69 L-78 Chevelle. And at no point have I answered my own question posed in the very first post. certainly all my comments are made in good humor with tongue in cheek...OK?

But if anyone wants to comment on the original question..I'm still pretty interested in everyones POV. and there is no wrong or right answer. Even though I firmly believe the Judge is the most recognisable Musle Car of all to the GENERAL public..certainly it's most likley not even in the top ten as far as desirability, rarity or value.

Sorry, if I ruffled any feathers.

[x Baldwin Motion]

Dang it, it looks like this is over and I did not opine.