The limited production, high performance cars will always hold their value at the top of the heap. But it still comes down to personal preference that motivates a lot of people to buy what they want. And in today's economy there are plenty of people who are capable of buying what they want regardless of the cost. As for new vs old, I like em all and I keep going back and forth. The 4th gen Camaros/Firebirds offer a ton of performance and handling/braking for an affordable cost. The older cars give you that feeling of raw power. The pro-touring cars give you the combination of old looks with modern performance. I'll take 1 of each!