Jason,
Here are more numbers to trace down.
Med. Aqua (Only available in 60% gloss)
Dupont: 9005-L
R-M: 62036
Ditzler (PPG): 12533
Dark Aqua
DuPont: 4429-L (flat), 96221 (60% gloss)
R-M: 63B23 (flat), no 60% formula listed
Ditzler (PPG): DIA-12753 (flat), 9012-L (60% gloss)
The tops of the doors should be the 60% gloss, as well as any other non-dash related trim. The rest of the dash is the flat. Use the 60% on the steering column, but mix it with 1/2 the reducer so it's a little flatter than the doors but a little glossier than the dash. That's the way they were.
I hope this helps.
Verne